Iliad book vs troy movie

Briseis is a trojan priestess and hectors cousin, captured during the attack on apollos. Classics analysis the iliad vs troy sunday, 14 october 2012. The two warriors race three times around troy iliad book xxii, this is an example of the differences between the two because as this clip describes hector actually stays and fights to his death with honor. Because in greek mythology, the fate of a hero has been decided by the prophey or gods. One major similarity of homers the iliad and petersens troy is their depiction of achilles, a demigod thought to be invincible.

Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the movie troy essay sample. In homers iliad, the gods played a major part in the trojan war. The iliad and the movie troy essay iliad, achilles. The iliad portrays helen disgusted with the cowardly paris, wishing he had. Troy, based on the iliad, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers classic and one cannot help noticing the major differences between the book and the movie. Wolfgang peterson tackles the job of bringing the epic of homers the iliad to the big screen in his film troy. The iliad homer s the iliad is one of the greatest epic poems ever written. A major difference in the film was that there were no intervening or actions of the gods whatsoever, whereas in th.

Comparison of the iliad, the odyssey, and the aeneid. In the iliad, patroclus was not the cousin of achilles, only a friend. The ancient legend of troy, recorded in homers epic poem the iliad oxford trans. Whats the difference between the iliad the book and troy. The iliad demonstrates the close interactions between the gods and goddesses and their followers. The movie troy written by david benioff and directed by wolfgang petersen was inspired by the iliad, an ancient greek poem about the time of warrior achilles argument with king agamemnon during the trojan war. If the film remained same as the poem iliad then the movie would have received more limited ratings and decrease the. Get an answer for how is menelaus portrayed in the film troy and homers iliad. Differences between troy movie and iliad free essays. The producer of the movie troy, did a very good job of making it similar to the book the iliad. The differences between the book iliad and the movie troy. The iliad tells only a small portion of the 10 year trojan warabout 9 weeks, i believe. Comparison of book iliad and the film troy free download as word doc.

In the movie paris and menelaus offer to duel each other and end the war before it begins. Get an answer for what are the differences between the movie troy and the iiliad. Wolfgang petersens 2004 film, inspired by the iliad, edited out all the gods and nymphs, and made the war into an action movie, supposedly. Briseis remains with achilles until after his death. Therefore, there are obvious deviations from the book such as the length of the trojan war, and the absence of celestial participation in the war. However, even though it is directly influenced by the poem, troy does not stay true to the poem for the entire movie. This breaches the terms of an agree set up between the leaders so the greeks attack. However, in the movie troy the gods are barely even mentioned, and are only mentioned when referred to when signs are received. Within the iliad, the gods take sides within the trojan war and are seen fighting amongst the common soldiers. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the movie troy with reference to what the movie has brought to modern day western culture. Why is achilles so stubborn in both the iliad and movie. James holoka, professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that despite this list he did enjoy the movie. It is an epic poem, with 24 chapters, based on the attack on troy by the mycenaeans.

This movie, troy, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers original, as are almost all stories that are made into movies, unfortunately. One of the most noticeable differences between the book and the movie is the absence of the gods. Ive got a paper to write do i do anything but write papers. People paused to observe single combats between the heroes and the movie does a great job of showing the drama from those combats to the extravagant funerals though it was a little too early for the coins on the eyes to the interpersonal relationships between such characters as. Last may, wolfgang petersen directed a movie based on the iliad. Though both stories consist of ensemble casts, achilles clearly stands out as their hero. Yet given that he knows his fate, he wont stop fighting for himself. How does the film about troy in greek mythology differ. Robert fitzgerald university press 1974 has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film troy 2004, wolfgang peterson.

Paris and menelaus offer to duel each other and end the war before it begins. Some pieces of materials will be quoted to support my understanding that in the iliad of homer, briseis is more than an object in achilless eyes. One of the major differences between the two texts is the role of the greek gods. The iliad over the thousands of years that the epic story the iliad has survived, there has no doubt been some form of alteration to homers original. Set during the trojan war, the tenyear siege of the city of troy ilium by a coalition of greek states, it tells of the battles and events during the. And homer would have loved the combat scenes though the iliad itself is a lot. The differences consisting of hector running away from achilles in the iliad and a long and glorious battle between them both in the movie troy.

Similarities and differences between the iliad and the. The poem shows the lives of the soldiers during the trojan war, the battles, honor, and revenge schultz. Quora user i disagree with you about the second point of view you put forward. Homers iliad via the movie troy 2004 professor edith hall. The iliad v troy comparsions between the modern film. In the iliad, homer portrays achilles as a demigod. The movie also continues on after the end of the iliad, which ends with the king of troy, priam getting his son, hectors body back from achilles, who had killed him and taken the body back to the greek camp. The horse is pushed to the gates of troy and greeks announce to troy that the horse is a gift to seal a peace agreement. The iliad is an epic poem consisting of 23 books by homer, which focuses on 50 days in the ninth year of the trojan war, whereas the movie troy directed by wolfgang petersen tells the whole 10 year story of the myth. Produced by units in malta, mexico and britains shepperton studios, the film features an ensemble cast led by brad pitt, eric bana, and orlando bloom. A comparison of the differences between the book iliad and.

Differences between troy movie and the iliad essay example. One other difference between hectors portrayal in the iliad and the movie is. Iliad being a lengthy text, it is impossible to include every detail in a movie. Achilless myrmidons sack apollos temple before the rest of the greek forces arrive, effectively starting the war. Since the film troy is based off the iliad, obviously there are many similarities between these texts. The poem is loosely portrayed in the 2004 film, troy, screenplay written by david benioff. The reason of these differences in the film troy and the iliad are to convenience of the director and for entertainment. The film also omits a lot of characters and subplots from the iliad.

Differences between troy movie and the iliad paper the iliad verses troy i n the movie its stated that agamemnon brought the kings together for this war, which really isnt true. What are the differences between the movie troy and the iiliad. Both population and physical size of troy are off by a factor of ten in the film. Achilles is the son of peleus and the seanymph thetis. Iliad audience troy audience an epic poem is a long, narrative poem that is usually about heroic deeds and events that are significant to the culture of the poet.

Although homer is said to have written the epic in 725 bce and the fall of troy supposedly have happened almost 400 years before the epic was written, but people do take homers word and hold them as truths. This was a major plot point in homers iliad, as the gods who fought on the battlefield had somewhat of an influence on the outcome of each battle and eventually the outcome of the war. Achilles in troy vs the iliad general discussion non. Smellin of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the bigbudget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. Helen had many powerful suitors and her father was too afraid to pick one of them for her husband in fear of offending the others. The iliad is the oldest surviving work of greek literature, written by homer in the 8th century bc. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film the guardian. Yet eventually his personal struggle, either his personality, or even reactionresistance. They would earn less money for the publishing company. In the movie briseis comes from lyrnessus, and is captured by the aecheans before the siege of troy. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. Throughout the lesson, well talk about the similarities and differences between.

Looking at wolfgang petersons blockbuster troy 2004, the lecture describes the genesis of the iliad between the mycenaean late bronze age and. In book 1 of the iliad, who do you think is most to blame for the rage of achilles, achilles or. What are the differences of troy and iliad answers. The point is that in the movie, we see helen glad that paris didnt finish the fight and that he chose love over honor. Hector the fight between hector and achilles is told in different ways with the iliad and troy. The are many similarities and many difference, in the iliad by homer and the movie troy, for achilles character. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been. Iliad epic poem vs troy epic contemporary film by iain. Iliad epic poem vs troy epic contemporary film what is an epic. Hektor in the iliad, homer portrays the trojan war and the siege of troy. The most powerful warrior in the the iliad and in troy. Some major differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersens film troy, is that there was no mention of the gods being participants in the battle of troy.

When paris kidnapped helen from menelaus, they were bound to honor their promise and help to return her. Whats the difference between the iliad the book and troy the movie. Part three troy the iliad agamemnon did not do this in the book agamemnon brought the kings together for war the greeks won the war, and the trojan horse let them win. This movie, troy, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers. How is menelaus portrayed in the film troy and homers iliad. What are differences in achilles character in troy and. First off, homers iliad was the main source of influence for wolfgang petersens film, troy.

Achilless myrmidons sack apollos temple before the. Book and film comparison the iliad became adapted into a film during 2004 called troy, in which the story was both dramatically and subtly changed in its adaptation. Meneleuss death, pariss escape, helens situation, and the trojan princesses. Achilles commands the myrmidons, soldiers from his homeland of phthia in greece, his wrath at agamemnon for taking his war prize, briseis, turns into the the main subject in the iliad. Troy is a 2004 epic historical war drama film directed by wolfgang petersen and written by david benioff. If the film remained same as the poem iliad then the movie would have received more limited ratings and decrease the amount of the audience. Comparison of book iliad and the film troy achilles iliad scribd. Major differences between the homers iliad and the film troy. Already have nine years of great zeus gone by, whereas in the film troy it only took 17 days. The movie however continues on passed this point, going on to show the end of the war. What are the differences between the movie troy and the.